Jump to content

Kitten Tab Factor 2012: Sunburn Summer edition


Dave.
 Share

Recommended Posts

Not sure if we should go outside Muse - at least we know everyone here likes them :LOL:

 

I fucking hate Muse.

 

Also, there must be Biffy... and I think the final round should be a fairly unheard of song that has no tabs on the internet so that we get a chance to see peoples interpretation skills

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One Direction covers :pope:

 

Seriously. Here are some thoughts based on the last one:

 

1. Definitely do an anonymous Soundcloud entry system. Eliminates stupidity and favoritism

 

2. Someone else brought up the issue of "I like this song better, so I'll vote for that person." I know everyone likes their freedom (except North Koreans), but why not have everyone do the same song per round so it's actually a fair comparison? If we're eliminating the favoritism factor of videos, let's also eliminate the favoritism factor based on song choice.

 

3. I like the idea of bringing in more variety in band choices. Maybe some Foo Fighters or Biffy? They seem to be big, plus I'd enjoy voting on some The Captain covers :awesome:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

One Direction covers :pope:

 

Seriously. Here are some thoughts based on the last one:

 

1. Definitely do an anonymous Soundcloud entry system. Eliminates stupidity and favoritism

 

2. Someone else brought up the issue of "I like this song better, so I'll vote for that person." I know everyone likes their freedom (except North Koreans), but why not have everyone do the same song per round so it's actually a fair comparison? If we're eliminating the favoritism factor of videos, let's also eliminate the favoritism factor based on song choice.

3. I like the idea of bringing in more variety in band choices. Maybe some Foo Fighters or Biffy? They seem to be big, plus I'd enjoy voting on some The Captain covers :awesome:

 

Was just gonna mention this, there could easily be favouritism if someone likes a song more.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Personally I think there should be a choice of 4 other bands apart from mooz, Foos/Biffy/QOTSA/TCV

 

Or replace one of them with Radiohead. TCV I honestly think should be there, they've got some challenging stuff and there's loads of room for improv, it'd be a good way to show off skillz

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Batman.
Personally I think there should be a choice of 4 other bands apart from mooz, Foos/Biffy/QOTSA/TCV

 

Or replace one of them with Radiohead. TCV I honestly think should be there, they've got some challenging stuff and there's loads of room for improv, it'd be a good way to show off skillz

 

I don't know, I reckon we should have a set choice for a Muse song, and then be able to choose our own song from another band. And yes I know that it may encourage favouritism based on song choice, but it'd be much less restrictive, and we could always just encourage people to vote based on the skill of the cover, not the song.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't know, I reckon we should have a set choice for a Muse song, and then be able to choose our own song from another band. And yes I know that it may encourage favouritism based on song choice, but it'd be much less restrictive, and we could always just encourage people to vote based on the skill of the cover, not the song.

 

But choosing our own would open up a huge can of worms, most people would have different stuff so it'd just be harder to vote. I like the idea of a set Muse choice and a set other band choice per round.

 

But we need to find a way to make people vote purely for the playing/singing and not because of the songs...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But we need to find a way to make people vote purely for the playing/singing and not because of the songs...

 

Just have a single song each round - and say that we have 6 rounds? 3 Muse, 3 other bands, alternate each week :) Then they would have to vote based on the playing/singing

 

You could even have a "free" round where people can do any song they want, if they think that they weren't able to do a song that they wanted - just incase

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Batman.
But choosing our own would open up a huge can of worms, most people would have different stuff so it'd just be harder to vote. I like the idea of a set Muse choice and a set other band choice per round.

 

But we need to find a way to make people vote purely for the playing/singing and not because of the songs...

 

But not choosing our own would open up a small can of bears, if you will. Because some people here don't listen to or particularly like TCV or QOTSA etc

 

E.G. ME

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We just vote don't we? :erm: You should be the Soundcloud poster!

 

Yeah use soundcloud. All entries uploaded as user1 /user 2 etc. no names

 

I could be the soundcloud poster. Something like people email me their entries, and I post up the files.

 

Should we have some sort of a constant for everyone, like a drumtrack?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I could be the soundcloud poster. Something like people email me their entries, and I post up the files.

 

Should we have some sort of a constant for everyone, like a drumtrack?

 

I wouldn't know about the Drum Track - People might be able to come up with different arrangements of a song :)

 

But we should see what everyone else says

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But not choosing our own would open up a small can of bears, if you will. Because some people here don't listen to or particularly like TCV or QOTSA etc

 

E.G. ME

 

Well true, but I don't massively like Biffy, I'd still be up for doing it, if it was just a round or two

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Batman.
Well true, but I don't massively like Biffy, I'd still be up for doing it, if it was just a round or two

 

Well same, I'm just saying though - doing songs of bands that we don't even like just takes all the fun out of it, and makes it dull.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well same, I'm just saying though - doing songs of bands that we don't even like just takes all the fun out of it, and makes it dull.

 

Yeah that's a good point. But if we had the choice of Muse or another band per round you could just do the Muse choice..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

×
×
  • Create New...