magazine Q 250 - Three albums of Muse voted in top 30 for "Best Albums of Q's Lifetime"

[uchu]

Q's next issue is No.295 and it features "Best Albums of Q's Lifetime" (which means the best albums in about past 25 years), three albums of Muse are in top 30 by readers vote.

 

Top 30 list as follows:

1, OK Computer / Radiohead

2, Nevermind / Nirvana

3, (What's The Story) Morning Glory? / Oasis

4, Definitely Maybe / Oasis

5, Whatever People Say I Am / Arctic Monkeys

6, The Joshua Tree / U2

7, The Stone Roses / The Stone Roses

8, The Bends / Radiohead

9, Achtung Baby / U2

10, Black Holes And Revelations / Muse

11, Is This It? / The Strokes

12, A Rush Of Blood To The Head / Coldplay

13, Parklife / Blur

14, Screamadelica / Primal Scream

15, White Blood Cells / The White Stripes

16, In The Aeroplane Over The Sea / Newtral Milk Hotel

17, Hot Fuss / The Killers

18, Kid A / Radiohead

19, Funeral / Arcade Fire

20, American Idiot / Green Day

21, The Holy Bible / Manic Street Preachers

22, Absolution / Muse

23, In Rainbows / Radiohead

24, Only By The Night / Kings Of Leon

25, Demon Days / Gorillaz

26, Origin Of Symmetry / Muse

27, Appetite For Destruction / Guns 'N' Roses

28, Urban Hymns / The Verve

29, Automatic For The People / R.E.M.

30, Loveless / My Bloody Valentine

 

I got this list from a Japanese writer's blog and I couldn't find any info about this on qthemusic.com yet. The full listing can be longer and Showbiz and The Resistance might be there, hopefully..

 

If you found any official source from Q, let me know.

 

EDIT:

53, The Resistance

127, Showbiz

[chudenk]

This is joke

[Hat]

This is joke

Really? it's a pretty okay list for pop-rock.

[Uccellino]

I wouldn't agree with the order, putting BH&R above Abso and Origin.

[TomWillett97]

OK Computer higher than Nevermind

And abso and oos are a lot better than a lot of albums higher than them

And BHAR is not better than Abso and OoS

[Iddy]

Loveless should be number 1.

[Gareeh]

it's almost good, except absolution should be 10th and Oasis have two songs in the top 5.

[JoshyBarth]

Correct order of Muse Albums imo everything else is a bit iffy... for example, Oasis because I dislike them

[Rusty Shackleford]

Kid A should be higher...especially over Black Holes And Revelations which is Muse's second worst album.

[Zaphod Chizzlebrox]

I would say Kid A and The Bends should swap places. Nice spread otherwise, although I definitely disagree with BHAR being number 10. It's by reader vote though, so that's why the albums are all in the wrong order. Except OK Computer. Radiohead nailed it with that one.

[LyraSilvertongue]

Q's next issue is No.250 and it features "Best Albums of Q's Lifetime" (which means the best albums in about past 25 years), three albums of Muse are in top 30 by readers vote.

 

Top 30 list as follows:

1, OK Computer / Radiohead

2, Nevermind / Nirvana

3, (What's The Story) Morning Glory? / Oasis

4, Definitely Maybe / Oasis

5, Whatever People Say I Am / Arctic Monkeys

6, The Joshua Tree / U2

7, The Stone Roses / The Stone Roses

8, The Bends / Radiohead

9, Achtung Baby / U2

10, Black Holes And Revelations / Muse

11, Is This It? / The Strokes

12, A Rush Of Blood To The Head / Coldplay

13, Parklife / Blur

14, Screamadelica / Primal Scream

15, White Blood Cells / The White Stripes

16, In The Aeroplane Over The Sea / Newtral Milk Hotel

17, Hot Fuss / The Killers

18, Kid A / Radiohead

19, Funeral / Arcade Fire

20, American Idiot / Green Day

21, The Holy Bible / Manic Street Preachers

22, Absolution / Muse

23, In Rainbows / Radiohead

24, Only By The Night / Kings Of Leon

25, Demon Days / Gorillaz

26, Origin Of Symmetry / Muse

27, Appetite For Destruction / Guns 'N' Roses

28, Urban Hymns / The Verve

29, Automatic For The People / R.E.M.

30, Loveless / My Bloody Valentine

 

I got this list from a Japanese writer's blog and I couldn't find any info about this on qthemusic.com yet. The full listing can be longer and Showbiz and The Resistance might be there, hopefully..

 

If you found any official source from Q, let me know.

 

I've never even heard of Newtral Milk Hotel

[Tesseract]

I like Radiohead but they are so, so over-rated. Especially Kid A. OK Computer is great though. I would still put Abso at number one.

[LyraSilvertongue]

I like Radiohead but they are so, so over-rated. Especially Kid A. OK Computer is great though. I would still put Abso at number one.

 

+1

[nohopeinfear]

I've never even heard of Newtral Milk Hotel

 

It was Bellamys side project, sponsored by Dairy Crest and Premier Inn

[Jimmyneutron]

I wouldn't agree with the order, putting BH&R above Abso and Origin.

 

I would agree with it. BH&R will be more of a timeless and memorable album

[nohopeinfear]

I would agree with it. BH&R will be more of a timeless and memorable album

 

:stunned:

 

 

:stunned:

[LyraSilvertongue]

It was Bellamys side project, sponsored by Dairy Crest and Premier Inn

 

Seriously though, I really hadn't heard of them before today

[bruce57]

I've never even heard of Newtral Milk Hotel

Its actually Neutral Milk Hotel, and they are awesome

[futurellama]

Anyone who says that any Muse album should have been number one is clearly an idiot.

 

But then again there are two Oasis albums in the top 5 so Muse could probably have won this

[a-museing]

Anyone who says that any Muse album should have been number one is clearly an idiot.

 

Thanks. :erm: Ever heard of an opinion?

[LyraSilvertongue]

Anyone who says that any Muse album should have been number one is clearly an idiot.

 

Why? OK Computer is number 1 but I love Absolution more. Why does that make me an idiot?

[haze015]

Thanks. :erm: Ever heard of an opinion?

 

The list was made using lots of people's opinions.

 

Muse make some great music, but shite albums. Should have been the other way round.

[futurellama]

I love Origin more than I love OK Computer but I can still recognise that OK Computer is technically the better album.

[a-museing]

The list was made using lots of people's opinions.

 

Muse make some great music, but shite albums. Should have been the other way round.

 

I didn't mean Q had to vote it to the top. I was referring to Futurellama's comment that people who think Muse should have been on top are 'clearly idiots.'

 

I love Origin more than I love OK Computer but I can still recognise that OK Computer is technically the better album.

 

And people who think otherwise are idiots?

[LyraSilvertongue]

I love Origin more than I love OK Computer but I can still recognise that OK Computer is technically the better album.

 

I'm sure the people who voted chose the albums they love the most, not the ones they thought were 'technically' better.