Jump to content

hairolfitri

Members
  • Posts

    260
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by hairolfitri

  1. Let's take my personal favourites into account – the songs that I rate 10/10 (i.e. my favourite songs) are Citizen Erased, Stockholm Syndrome, Take a Bow, Dead Inside, Hysteria, Exogenesis 3, Megalomania, FAWY, The Handler, Supremacy, Showbiz, Starlight and Muscle Museum.

     

    I guess most fans may consider the likes of Citizen Erased, Stockholm Syndrome, Hysteria and perhaps The Handler to be some of Muse's best songs, but I can already say, by observation, that Falling Away with You and Starlight are poorly received by fans on this board. And granted, perhaps these two songs do not display Muse at their finest. That being said, I still love these songs because of personal preference; I thought FAWY is Muse's best "softer" songs and I love that middle part of Starlight so much that I could repeat those 10 seconds over and over again.

     

    Nonetheless, I do not believe that any of Muse's other songs could be legitimately called their "best" (not even Knights of Cydonia, Map of the Problematique, and MK Ultra – which I personally do not enjoy and believe are overrated), so to speak. So, to a certain degree, I do consider my 13 favourite songs to be their best.

  2. Tallied.. Based on 44 voters

     

    Showbiz: Overdue (15 votes), Sober (10 votes), Falling Down (7 votes)

    Origin of Symmetry: Feeling Good (24 votes), Screenager (15 votes), Dark Shines (3 votes)

    Absolution: Endlessly (11 votes), The Small Print & Blackout (5 votes)

    Black Holes and Revelations: Soldier's Poem (24 votes), Starlight & Exo-Politics (5 votes)

    The Resistance: Guiding Light (18 votes), I Belong to You (17 votes), Undisclosed Desires (5 votes)

    The 2nd Law: Save Me (15 votes), Explorers (9 votes), Big Freeze (6 votes)

    Drones: Drones (15 votes), Revolt (14 votes), Mercy (6 votes)

  3. And may I stress the ONE.

     

    Showbiz: Showbiz

    Origin of Symmetry: Citizen Erased

    Absolution: Falling Away with You (Because SS and Hyseria is so cliche lol)

    Black Holes & Revelations: Take a Bow

    The Resistance: Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 3: Redemption (Counted as separate tracks)

    The 2nd Law: Madness (Once again going for the non-conventional pick)

    Drones: Reapers

  4. Showbiz - Overdue (worst Muse song ever, atrocious)

    Origin of Symmetry - Feeling Good (duh.)

    Absolution - Blackout (this is so difficult, love them all)

    BH&R - Assassin (I just never got very much into it, it is a beast for playing though)

    Resistance - Guiding Light (duh once again)

    Drones - Revolt (duhduhduh)

     

    You forgot The 2nd Law.

  5. This was only easy because I based it on the rating and ranking I gave in the other thread. Also, I did not include B-sides, or bonus tracks.

     

    Showbiz

    Origin of Symmetry

    Absolution

    Black Holes & Revelations

    The Resistance

    The 2nd Law

    Drones

     

    10/10:

    1. Citizen Erased

    2. Stockholm Syndrome

    3. Take a Bow

    4. Dead Inside

    5. Hysteria

    6. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 3: Redemption

    7. Megalomania

    8. Falling Away with You + Interlude

    9. The Handler

    10. Supremacy

    11. Showbiz

    12. Starlight

    13. Muscle Museum

     

    9/10:

    14. The Globalist

    15. Plug In Baby

    16. Micro Cuts

    17. Invincible

    18. United States of Eurasia + Collateral Damage

    19. Sing for Absolution

    20. Escape

    21. [JFK] + Defector

    22. Resistance

    23. Endlessly

    24. City of Delusion

    25. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 1: Overture

    26. Butterflies & Hurricanes

    27. The 2nd Law: Unsustainable

    28. Sunburn

    29. Aftermath

    30. Madness

    31. Prelude + Survival

    32. Knights of Cydonia

    33. Bliss

     

    8/10:

    34. Hate This and I’ll Love You

    35. Space Dementia

    36. Hyper Music

    37. Reapers

    38. Supermassive Black Hole

    39. Exo-Politics

    40. I Belong to You + Mon cœur s’ouvre à ta voix

    41. Revolt

    42. Intro + Apocalyse Please

    43. Uno

    44. Animals

    45. Hoodoo

    46. Guiding Light

    47. Panic Station

    48. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 2: Cross Pollination

    49. Ruled by Secrecy

    50. New Born

    51. Uprising

     

    7/10:

    52. Cave

    53. Dark Shines

    54. The 2nd Law: Isolated System

    55. [Drill Sergeant] + Psycho

    56. Follow Me

    57. Map of the Problematique

    58. MK Ultra

    59. Time is Running Out

    60. Thoughts of a Dying Atheist

    61. Unintended

    62. Assassin

    63. Blackout

     

    6/10:

    64. Unnatural Selection

    65. Big Freeze

    66. Falling Down

    67. Screenager

    68. Feeling Good

    69. Mercy

    70. Explorers

    71. Soldier’s Poem

    72. Drones

    73. Fillip

     

    5/10:

    74. Undisclosed Desires

    75. Overdue

    76. The Small Print

    77. Liquid State

    78. Sober

     

    4/10:

    79. Save Me

  6. Wikipedia says this: "As a genre, pop music is extremely eclectic, often borrowing elements from other styles including urban, dance, rock, Latin and country; nonetheless, there are core elements which define pop. Such elements include generally short to medium-length songs, written in a basic format (often the verse-chorus structure), as well as the common employment of repeated choruses, melodic tunes, and hooks."

     

    :LOL:

  7. While it stands for "popular" it's still a music genre rather than just music that's popular at the time.

    And DI feels way more pop than rock to me.

    Of course, they've been putting out "poppy" rock songs since... ever, really.

     

    And how do you define that music genre? (Personally, I would say pop songs encompass some of the "softer" and not-quite-blaring-loud songs by Muse, i.e. the songs I've listed in a previous post.)

  8. No, I don't have a problem with people disliking upbeat songs, it's just that when Revolt first came out, a lot of people seemed to just go "too upbeat, worst song on the album." Which didn't seem like fair judgement to me, then again, I love the song, so what do I know, right?

     

    Lol exactly. They'd compare Revolt to Big Freeze and say those two are the "poppiest" and most upbeat of their respective albums, thereby labelling them the worst of the bunch.

  9. :unsure: How exactly do you define a pop song? Because apparently a large number of you agree on what can be labelled a pop song by Muse, while I on the other hand, label Starlight, FAWY, Mercy, Endlessly, Undisclosed Desires and Big Freeze as some of Muse's pop songs. And I never considered Dead Inside a pop song.

     

    EDIT: Pop stands for popular right? If so, then by technical definition, I'd label the likes of Supermassive Black Hole, Time is Running Out, Plug In Baby, Neutron Star Collision, Uprising, Survival, Madness, Starlight and maybe Dead Inside as pop songs, because they are the more of the commercial hits by Muse.

  10. But people have made loads of LONG posts about why they don't like the song. Generally when someone asks a question like that, they haven't really cared to actually find out. We even have threads where the tracks are reviewed individually.

     

    And my post wasn't aimed at you so I'm not sure why you're defending yourself.

     

    Lol guess I can see your point, it was just a general wonderment but I wouldn't be swayed even if someone wrote a long post as to why they disliked the song.

     

    Carry on.

  11. Why would anybody even want a best of cd? Why would you want to buy another cd with music on it that you already have on a different cd? If you want the best of muse, why not just make your own? Don't really understand the logic in this thread :stunned:

     

    Can't say for other Muse fans, but I would buy it if that was the artwork. As for why anyone would want to buy a Greatest Hits album, I figure maybe for the people who are just about to get initiated into the Muse fanzone, or for those who are not exactly a diehard fan and don't have the time to buy or listen to all the songs in the 7 albums.

     

    One thing that I would change about Muse, if I had superpowers, is I would not have previously released all the songs that they've done. I'd save some for exclusive bonus tracks in their greatest hits album in case they ever wanted to publish one in the future. For instance, I wouldn't have previously released Fury, Hyper Chondriac Music, and maybe a demo like Instant Messenger, and save them as bonus tracks for a greatest hits album. That could attract diehard fans to buy their GH album.

  12. I literally just rephrased what CitizenAroused said.

     

    There's no need for anyone to get snappy, I just wondered why a lot of people name Revolt as their least favourite song from Drones, when I personally thought the chorus was pretty ace (or at least, better than the likes of Mercy or Drones, and maybe even Psycho).

     

    Because God forbid a legitimate opinion question is asked around here.

  13. I'd like to update all my rankings:

     

    Showbiz (1999)

    1. Showbiz (10/10)

    2. Muscle Museum (10/10)

    3. Escape (9/10)

    4. Sunburn (9/10)

    5. Hate This and I’ll Love You (8/10)

    6. Uno (8/10)

    7. Cave (7//10)

    8. Unintended (7/10)

    9. Falling Down (6/10)

    10. Fillip (6/10)

    11. Overdue (5/10)

    12. Sober (5/10)

    Score: 75%

     

    Origin of Symmetry (2001)

    1. Citizen Erased (10/10)

    2. Megalomania (10/10)

    3. Plug In Baby (9/10)

    4. Micro Cuts (9/10)

    5. Bliss (9/10)

    6. Space Dementia (8/10)

    7. Hyper Music (8/10)

    8. New Born (8/10)

    9. Dark Shines (7/10)

    10. Screenager (6/10)

    11. Feeling Good (6/10)

    Score: 82%

     

    Absolution (2003)

    1. Stockholm Syndrome (10/10)

    2. Hysteria (10/10)

    3. Falling Away with You + Interlude (10/10)

    4. Sing for Absolution (9/10)

    5. Endlessly (9/10)

    6. Butterflies & Hurricanes (9/10)

    7. Intro + Apocalyse Please (8/10)

    8. Ruled by Secrecy (8/10)

    9. Time is Running Out (7/10)

    10. Thoughts of a Dying Atheist (7/10)

    11. Blackout (7/10)

    12. The Small Print (5/10)

    Score: 83%

     

    Black Holes and Revelations (2006)

    1. Take a Bow (10/10)

    2. Starlight (10/10)

    3. Invincible (9/10)

    4. City of Delusion (9/10)

    5. Knights of Cydonia (9/10)

    6. Supermassive Black Hole (8/10)

    7. Exo-Politics (8/10)

    8. Hoodoo (8/10)

    9. Map of the Problematique (7/10)

    10. Assassin (7/10)

    11. Soldier’s Poem (6/10)

    Score: 83%

     

    The Resistance (2009)

    1. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 3: Redemption (10/10)

    2. I Belong to You + Mon cœur s’ouvre à ta voix (9/10)

    3. United States of Eurasia + Collateral Damage (9/10)

    4. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 1: Overture (9/10)

    5. Resistance (8/10)

    6. Guiding Light (8/10)

    7. Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 2: Cross Pollination (8/10)

    8. Uprising (7/10)

    9. MK Ultra (7/10)

    10. Unnatural Selection (6/10)

    11. Undisclosed Desires (5/10)

    Score: 79%

     

    The 2nd Law (2012)

    1. Prelude + Survival (9/10)

    2. Madness (9/10)

    3. Supremacy (9/10)

    4. The 2nd Law: Unsustainable (9/10)

    5. Animals (8/10)

    6. Panic Station (8/10)

    7. The 2nd Law: Isolated System (7/10)

    8. Follow Me (7/10)

    9. Big Freeze (5/10)

    10. Liquid State (5/10)

    11. Explorers (5/10)

    12. Save Me (4/10)

    Score: 71%

     

    Drones (2015)

    1. Reapers (10/10)

    2. Revolt (10/10)

    3. Dead Inside (10/10)

    4. The Handler (10/10)

    5. [JFK] + Defector (9/10)

    6. The Globalist (9/10)

    7. Aftermath (8/10)

    8. Mercy (7/10)

    9. [Drill Sergeant] + Psycho (6/10)

    10. Drones (5/10)

    Score: 84%

  14. Latest results:

     

    Showbiz:

    • Showbiz (39 votes)
    • Muscle Museum (34 votes)
    • Sunburn (33.5 votes)

     

    Origin of Symmetry:

    • Citizen Erased (35.5 votes)
    • Bliss (18 votes)
    • New Born (17.5 votes)

     

    Absolution:

    • Stockholm Syndrome (39 votes)
    • Hysteria (21 votes)
    • Butterflies & Hurricanes (20 votes)

     

    Black Holes & Revelations:

    • Map of the Problematique (32.5 votes)
    • Knights of Cydonia (26 votes)
    • Take a Bow (18.5 votes)

     

    The Resistance:

    • MK Ultra (31 votes)
    • Exogenesis: Symphony, Pt. 3: Redemption (20.66 votes)
    • Uprising (19 votes)

     

    The 2nd Law:

    • Animals (34 votes)
    • Survival (24.5 votes)
    • Supremacy (22 votes)

     

    Drones:

    • The Handler (42 votes)
    • Reapers (40 votes)
    • The Globalist (23.5 votes)

     

    The only difference now is Supremacy has beaten Isolated System by 2 votes.

×
×
  • Create New...