Jump to content

Recommended Posts

I honestly don't understand it. Explain to me what I'm missing? Maybe my ears/heart are broken

 

It’s just lovely. The soft acoustic finger work climbing up that C chord combined with the warbling synth arpeggios and rain/thunder. V intimate vibe with Dom counting in, Matt’s restrained vocals and the sweet, nostalgic but sad lyrics that sound hopeful and hopeless at the same time. Then that ultimate emotional release at the end (without going OTT) before fading back to how the song started.

 

I’d be in floods if I ever saw it live, v high up on my requests bucket list.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It’s just lovely. The soft acoustic finger work climbing up that C chord combined with the warbling synth arpeggios and rain/thunder. V intimate vibe with Dom counting in, Matt’s restrained vocals and the sweet, nostalgic but sad lyrics that sound hopeful and hopeless at the same time. Then that ultimate emotional release at the end (without going OTT) before fading back to how the song started.

 

I’d be in floods if I ever saw it live, v high up on my requests bucket list.

 

I gave it another listen with what you said in mind...it still fell flat to my ears, but I suppose that says more about me than it does the song. I love it when Matt goes over the top, lol. Thanks for taking the time to explain the appeal to me!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I gave it another listen with what you said in mind...it still fell flat to my ears, but I suppose that says more about me than it does the song. I love it when Matt goes over the top, lol. Thanks for taking the time to explain the appeal to me!

 

Same, I think Muse’s bombast is their biggest draw but that makes any well done moments of restraint more impressive and refreshing for me.

 

Hate This And I'll Love You

 

just droppin in with the assist

 

http://board.muse.mu/showthread.php?t=3086

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
How is HTAILY overrated? Hardly anyone ever seems to talk about it. I've always viewed it as maybe their most UNDERrated track.

 

The fact that anyone rates it makes it overrated in my eyes :LOL:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On the whole, I don’t tend to think many (if any) Muse songs are particularly overrated, but a fair few posters really seem to like IBTY, which to me at least would be very low in the ranking of all their songs

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
How is HTAILY overrated? Hardly anyone ever seems to talk about it.

 

Same, I haven't seem anyone talking about it in here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a vague memory of mentioning I didn't really care for HTAILY at some point and catching a lot of flack for it and people saying it's one of the best songs on Showbiz. Perhaps it was on another site actually, but whatever. On repeated listens, I actually came to enjoy the song a lot more, but I still take over half the rest of Showbiz over it. It's pretty much a couple steps above Escape, Overdue, and Sober, and not really on par with anything else for me.

 

So that's why it strikes me as overrated.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The fact that anyone rates it makes it overrated in my eyes :LOL:

 

Actually just vomited in my mouth a lil

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

HTAILY is god tier Muse.

 

Tbh, Exogenesis is hugely overrated. Everyone creams themselves over it as if it somehow legitimises Muse as a genuinely cerebral band when it's basically three sub-par Musey pieces stuck together in an extremely unsophisticated manner. Same goes for The Globalist.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

God, The Globalist is possibly the most generic Muse song ever...along with Mercy. A Morricone ripoff+a live jam+a cover with added vocals. Jfc Matt.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Tbh, Exogenesis is hugely overrated. Everyone creams themselves over it as if it somehow legitimises Muse as a genuinely cerebral band when it's basically three sub-par Musey pieces stuck together in an extremely unsophisticated manner. Same goes for The Globalist.

 

I enjoy the first and third parts of Exogenesis but the second is pretty naff.

 

God, The Globalist is possibly the most generic Muse song ever...along with Mercy. A Morricone ripoff+a live jam+a cover with added vocals. Jfc Matt.

 

Agreed with all the Globalist points as well. Best part is the little lead guitar line in the heavy section and it only lasts for five seconds.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hmm, let’s see. I agree with recent comments about Exogenesis and The Globalist. I always thought Exogenesis was hampered by its pretentious billing as a “symphony” despite there being no repeating/developing themes across the three movements, and it featured some of the band’s most basic orchestration at the time. I’ve softened on it over the years because I still think it’s a pleasant enough listen and admire Matt’s ambition to self-produce and arrange in spite of his limitations (which weren’t so obvious beforehand). Also, it felt like it rounded out a mostly satisfactory conclusion to its album, unlike what T2L and Drones managed. I still feel defiant if people call it a masterpiece though :p !

 

I enjoy aspects of The Globalist to an extent, but it suffers from sounding like multiple pieces (some more complete than others) merged into one rather than a single, well-developed composition. Again, a lot of my feelings about the track have to do with expectation vs reality – for years, I assumed the band could make an excellent 10/15 minute song full of developing ideas, got excited when I heard they were actually trying, and felt confused/disappointed when it didn’t seem to work as naturally as I'd hoped. I thought the rising bit in the heavy section was the most amateurish-sounding/poorly executed moment I’d heard on a Muse record to date – there was a real sense that Dom and Chris were completely out of sync with Matt’s (fine) guitar line/the backing strings ... which had never happened before, in my opinion. Back when I was listening to the first four albums, I’d never have dreamed all three members of the band and a producer would go on to sign off on an arrangement like that. A bit harsh of me, I know :LOL:!!

 

I mean, in fairness, I don’t know that either of those would qualify as “most overrated Muse songs”, as I get the impression quite a few people share similar views on them.

 

For a couple of other honourable mentions that don’t quite fit the bill:

 

The Small Print – pacy and fairly engaging, but not a great example of their heavy side for me. My least favourite Absolution track along with ToaDA.

Fury – enjoyable enough, but not even one of my favourite B-sides. Never quite understood why it became such a popular/requested song.

Liquid State (sort of?) – as much as I appreciate the gesture of including a couple of Chris’s songs on T2L, there are no two Muse tracks I’d have rather been B-sides. A lot of people seem to be more neutral or positive about LS than me, so it seems overrated by default haha!

 

In the end I’d probably settle on Assassin or (more controversially) Map of the Problematique :eek: ! Assassin is great for allowing Dom an opportunity to show off and giving the whole band a bit of a workout, but I’ve never quite taken to it the way a lot of people seem to have. Map is a good song, but I’m often surprised at just how positively people talk about it/how loyally the band have kept it in contention for live revivals. It’s been performed live at all of the Muse gigs I’ve been to so I’ve had plenty of exposure to the experience, and it’s always been good but never a highlight. Of the forgotten singles, I think Invincible and (maybe to a lesser extent) Sing For Absolution are the tricks they’re missing. I’d rather one of them use up a “singalong ballad” slot and add a bit of their colour/spacey-ness to the set. Map could be swapped out in favour of a number of more energetic songs without me minding :$

Edited by LoganMH

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Fury – enjoyable enough, but not even one of my favourite B-sides. Never quite understood why it became such a popular/requested song.

 

In the end I’d probably settle on Assassin or (more controversially) Map of the Problematique :eek: !

 

:stunned::wtf::noey:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't really know if Exogenesis is really that overrated except maybe by the band themselves during its promotion.

 

The fanbase opinion from what I've seen tends to be something similar to what Clunge said, especially if you were there for The Resistance build-up and were really expecting a symphony.

 

And outside the fanbase I haven't seen it gain them any high prestige or anything. I don't see people that kinda know Muse praise them for how they wrote a 15 minute symphony. The most popular ended up being Redemption because of the music video which everyone just sees as a nice piano ballad now.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...