smoledman
-
Posts
228 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Blogs
Events
Articles
Store
Downloads
Posts posted by smoledman
-
-
Welp. Anyways I don't really care about Anthony Fantano's opinion. I listened to the entire album and was thoroughly unimpressed by everything. At least on Drones we got some real bangers like 'Reapers'. Not a single track on this LP like that.
-
Well all the reviews are in and the consensus - the album sucks ass. Honestly this is where I get off the Muse train for good. I'll still go back and listen to the old songs, but I just can't give a rat's ass about this band anymore.
-
Kramnidorach
Nov 9, 2018
0
Can't blame Muse from trying new things. Sometimes, this worked well (Black Holes & revelations, Resistance), sometimes it worked about ok (Drones). Even 2nd law, which I didn't really like, had a few good songs. Here.. it's the void. Back are the electronic shenanigans from 2nd law, mixed in a more current manner, with the same Muse epic singing. yet, overall result doesn't feel fresh at all. And apart the Dark side maybe, nothing good popped to my hears. Easily the worst album of Muse of all times. Let's hear you in 3 years maybe. Yup, not even wanting to hear that garbage on tour this time (for the first time in almost 2 decades...)
Wow!
-
Ouch, only a 77/100 and 7.2/10 on Metacritic. Pretty much aligns with how I feel about this album. It's ok, but nothing special.
-
I'm not saying he doesn't practice or try to improve his skills, just that I'm missing all those interesting drum parts we used to get. Hopefully there will be some of that on the 5 songs we haven't heard.
-
I'm just concerned that Dom is falling into the Lars Ulrich area.. More businessman than caring about muscianship.
I mean I listened to 'Hoodoo' last night and I'm still blown away by the drumming on the "come to be" section. 12 years on and still killer.
-
Does anyone else feel that Dom has regressed a drummer in the last few years? It's almost as if they're using a drum machine half the time and Dom isn't bringing anything to the table. Remember how on "Screenager" he had the inspired idea to use bones, or his drum intro on "Map of the Problematique"? Where did it go?
-
I'm talking about tracks that are not typical intro-verse-chorus-bridge-verse-chorus-outro structure. Meaning not pop structures, but more acylical type songs found in progressive rock. Also bonus points for extra arpeggios, classical piano bits and odd time signatures.
A few off the top of my head:
Spiral Static
Space Dementia
Citizen Erased
Con-science
Butterflies & Hurricanes
Take a Bow
Hoodoo
Knights of Cydonia
Glorious
I Belong to You
Exogenesis Symphony
Animals
The 2nd Law: Unsustainable
The Globalist
The Dark Side
-
I've said that before as well. If Muse can't find it in themselves to drop any of the greatest hits for a rarity once in a while, at least they could try to rework a well known song for something fresh. They don't even change up the intros and outros to the songs. The snippets of Back in Black, Heartbreaker, House of the Rising Sun etc. might feel like a cool spontaneous improv to the newbie crowd but Muse have been doing the same ones for years.
I mean, what's the worst thing that could happen from playing a stripped back, piano version of Starlight? People might not do the hand-clap?
They're addicted to the adulation they get with those hand-clap songs. "Starlight", "Uprising", "Supermassive Black Hole", "Panic Station". I swear those songs will be played to the end of time before we'll ever hear the live debut of "Falling Away With You".
-
At least they're having fun with the new material.
-
In Rainbows > Muse
-
I believe Matt believes he can appeal to the 'urban' demographic by dumbing down the songs even further. He's sadly mistaken. No British white band will ever appeal like that.
-
I'd imagine the artwork fell for the same reason that singles fell, in that it just wasn't something people cared about too much. This is a very visual album so far and they've found a good place doing single releases online with videos rather than CDs with b-sides.
Are you saying that nobody cared about the artwork on BH&R? I personally found it very engaging and part of the whole experience. To me the artwork on the BH&R singles gives an extra 'heft' to the songs that is missing in the TR/T2L era.
-
SH feels like a heartfelt song. The other songs feel like the typical posturing.
-
Maybe it's just me and my unpopular opinions. But I feel the last 4 Muse LPs(TR, T2L, Drones, ST) have been very lazy & derivative. BH&R was already on the edge of that problem, but I feel it still exudes a confidence in the songwriting that is largely absent from what followed. Also notice another thing - no B-sides after 2006. Also look at artwork on BH&R(album, singles). All super classy and interesting. Artwork on everything 2009-present, not so much.
-
Anthony Fantano shared Pressure on Twitter. Wtf is happening with the melon?
If Fantano likes the song, it must be really really really bad.
-
Yeah, Fabri shouldn't be taken seriously. I mean he said St. Vincent doesn't write stale music while her last album was just shitty 2009 Lady Gaga impression
Exactly. A total shocker to see Annie Clark sell out like that. It's like in the history of music the only acts to never 'sell out':
The Beatles, Pink Floyd, King Crimson, Radiohead, David Bowie, Aimee Mann
-
Actually of the 5 songs so far, I'd say "Something Human" is the only one that measures up to the usual Muse standard of quality. I wonder if there will be a single heavy rock song on the album.
-
Not digging St Vincent's new album. The previous ones were good. But going back to Radiohead, I put on "In Rainbows" yesterday and it struck me that they're operating on a level 10000x higher than Muse.
-
So basically the song is about Matt feeling 'pressure' from us to write better songs. Fuh you Matt.
-
Honestly this song sounds like it could have been done by St. Vincent. Ugh.
-
Radiohead make this Muse look like musical pygmies.
-
The more I hear from this album makes me appreciate Drones. "Pressure" is possibly the worst Muse song ever.
-
Damn it's going to be tough for Muse. Nov 9 is also the day "The Beatles" 2018 super deluxe edition hits.
Album Eight: Simulation Theory
in Songs & Releases
Posted
I don't have a problem with the band wanting to do new things, it's that those things should be quality not shit. Ergo, Radiohead.