I was afraid I was the only one on this board to have similar impressions on first listen.
The length of the album has definitely helped me avoid skipping tracks, as with Drones and Simulation Theory. Their best since Absolution? I say no. Even with all its faults, Black Holes was a much more entertaining and overall better rounded album. I agree on the lyrics being repetitive, but at this point what else could they possibly talk about? I appreciate this album for being more of a kitsch-y mirror of Queen's Flash Gordon than the serious flashback to the 80's they attempted with ST.
Without a question, the last three songs are the best part of the album, Verona being the real standout.
I remember the radical difference in the audience's reaction from the Absolution to the Resistance tour, when they began going overboard with the orchestration. Went from people truly immersed in the music and jumping and screaming their hearts out to phones up in the air recording the screens and the laser show.
Do I want a return to basic rock (i.e., first two albums)? Not necessarily. Muse shine the brightest when they go bonkers experimenting, but when it is done without a clear aim it is rather vacuous and it fizzles out soon after it is cracked open.
I am going to give it a few more plays, and I hope/expect my opinion will improve.