I feel I'm a little late to the party to participate in the main discussion that I read on the first page of this thread, my fault for not coming here as much as a Muse fan should.
I defend Muse for SO many songs. In no order, I have defended at least once:
Showbiz, Supermassive black hole, Micro cuts, Hysteria, Ruled by Secrecy, Fury, I belong to you, Exogenesis Symphony, The Resistance, Uprising, Panic Station (Mainly the video), Supremacy.
However I repeatedly find myself defending:
Unsustainable, Neutron Star Collision and Survival.
I love Survival. I get the impression most people hate it, feel the lyrics are cheesy, and I kinda agree with that but the song itself is ****ing gold. The solo is amazing, the choir makes it sound SO powerful. I really like that song.