Jump to content

hyena17

Members
  • Posts

    393
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by hyena17

  1. Here’s a more condensed version I had in my head, just counting what I’d call ‘old fan favourites (that aren’t staples)’ over the last 3 album tours and looking purely at arenas and amphitheatres, no festivals:

     

    The Resistance (2010-2011)

    Songs counted: Ruled By Secrecy (7), Bliss (1), Citizen Erased (1), Butterflies & Hurricanes (1)

    Total gigs: 34

    Gigs where song(s) were played: 9 (26%)

     

    The 2nd Law (2013)

    Songs counted: Bliss (3), Sunburn (13), Map Of The Problematique (15), Dead Star (1), Agitated (4), Fury (1)

    Total gigs: 36

    Gigs where song(s) were played: 27 (75%)

     

    Drones (2015-2017)

    Songs counted: Bliss (4), Citizen Erased (3), Apocalypse Please (8), Map Of The Problematique (9), Stockholm Syndrome (8), Butterflies & Hurricanes (3)

    Total gigs: 31

    Gigs where song(s) were played: 23 (74%)

     

    They really don’t do that bad over there - in this specific aspect at least

     

    75% of gigs really means "probably one, but maybe two if you're lucky!!" at every gig. There are a lot of zeroes in there for no reason at all.

     

    And I wouldn't count SS as a rarity for Drones. it was played pretty regularly on the T2L tour.

     

    Seems like the best bet for US fans if you want a rare song, is go to the gigs at the very end of a tour, go to Montreal, or organize some kind of fan request. :LOL:

  2. Ok, so I went on setlist.fm and made a list of rarities on the last 2 NA tours. I didn't include the amphitheater tour because afaik, I think Map was played at a couple shows but that's it.

     

    T2L

    San Diego - Bliss

    LA - Bliss

    LA - Map, Sunburn, Save Me

    LA - Map

    Oakland - Sunburn

    Sac - 0

    Portland - Map, Sunburn

    Seattle - 0

    Edm - Map

    Calgary - 0

    Vanc - 0

    Sunrise - Bliss

    Tampa - 0

    Orlando - Map

    Cinn - 0

    Cleveland - 0

    Detroit - Map, Sunburn

    Chicago - Sunburn

    Columbus - Map

    Minn - Map, Sunburn

    St. Louis - Sunburn (around this time the setlist dropped to 20 from 21, save for 2 gigs)

    Tulsa - 0

    Houston - Map

    Dallas - Sunburn

    Phoenix - Map

    LV - Map

    Toronto - Map

    Toronto - Dead Star*

    Boston - Map

    Uncasville - Sunburn

    NY - Map

    NY - Sunburn, Dead Star*

    NJ - 0

    Montreal - Map

    Montreal - Sunburn, Micro Cuts

    ---Fall leg---

    Charlotte - Agitated

    Atlanta - Map, Sunburn, Agitated

    Nashville - NSC, US, Agitated

    Pittsburgh - Map, Fury*, US

    Philadelphia - 0

    DC - US

    SLC - Map, Sunburn, B&H, US

    Denver - Sunburn, US

     

     

    Drones

    Houston - 0

    Dallas - CE*

    Phoenix - AP

    Vanc - Bliss

    Seattle - CE

    Portland - Eurasia

    Oakland - 0

    LA - Eurasia

    LA - 0

    SD - AP

    LV - Map

    Chicago - Map

    Detroit - Map

    Toronto - CE and AP

    Q city - Map and AP

    Montreal - Bliss, Map, and AP

    Montreal - CE, Map, Eurasia

    Q city - Bliss, Map, Eurasia

    Boston - Map, AP

    NY - Map and AP

    NJ - Map, Eurasia

    Philly - Map, AP

    DC - Map and CE* and AP

     

    I put asterisks on the ones that were extenuating circumstances (fan request, etc). Red ones were played once.

     

    So yeah, that's not that great, IMO. Especially that whole first half of the Drones tour. More than I expected though for AP.

     

    Idk if Eurasia would be considered a rarity at all but I called it one for the Drones tour, idk maybe bc personally I really like it :LOL:

  3. They aren’t lazy, you don’t book a schedule that busy, put that much thought into the production and look like your face is gonna pop for half the songs just to jump in a bus and travel to the next one if you’re a lazy live band. Saying it doesn’t take effort to do what they do is just massively off the mark.

     

    I didn't say that. I said that it's lazy to pull out a generic setlist in one country and never change it. I didn't say they don't put in physical effort or emotion. If I thought that, I'd quit going to gigs. It's just that, for whatever reason, the setlists here are 99% predictable, which is not a good thing for a band that has been around as long as they have. There is definitely a lack of...something...going on here.

     

    Even then, just about every tour, they still go to the effort of throwing the hardcores a bone every now and again with a Bliss or Sunburn or CE or Butterflies etc., depsite knowing it’s really just for us.

     

    We will not get any of those four at any US arena shows. I'd bet on that.

     

    I've rarely seen more disengaged fans than when the band played The Globalist during the last tour and that consumed about 10% of their actual stage time for the whole show. Most of the people around me were just talking, especially during the quiet first section. I doubt that throwing in 4 minutes of Bliss, Muscle Museum or whatever could have been any worse for casual fans.

     

    This. I remember singing along with it and every once in a while getting broken out of my trance and looking around and nearly everyone around me (some on the barrier with me, some one row behind me) completely disengaged like they had no idea what was happening.

  4. This happens pretty often actually tbf, just look at almost any big gig where a rarity gets played.

     

    The point is, it's not even a realistic observation. I mean, he doesn't even know what the reaction would be because they don't play those rarities enough to even find out. There is a bigger percentage of people at any given gig that don't know any songs off a new album and will have the same reaction, so "killing the energy" or whatever isn't an excuse either. Nothing killed the energy of a gig the way that NKOK did, yet they continued with that.

     

    I mean, yeah maybe I'm reading too much into it, but the simplest explanation is just laziness. Play the generic radio hit setlist for the US, it gets good crowd reactions for the popular songs. It takes zero effort and they don't have to change anything up.

     

    And I guess there just aren't enough people standing there with their hands in their pockets during Resistance the way I do, then. :LOL:

  5. Basically the 2nd. It would totally not surprise me if they decided the US doesn't know Dead Star or Assassin so might as well drop those like Plug In Baby in 2013. Or replace it but I don't know what it would be replaced with that's on levels less interesting.

     

    That's what gets me. Even if half the audience doesn't know Dead Star, it shouldn't matter. Matt is so hung up on the US audiences "knowing" the songs. Guess what, the people paid money to see you because they like your stuff. Play something they don't know and they will be curious. Nobody is going to leave a gig or stand there with their hands in their pockets because a song they don't recognize is being played. :rolleyes: Fucking hell, they're the only band that seems to have this line of thought.

  6. yeah the US version of the medley will be the opening riff of CE (to troll the US fans that think it's a super rarity), a bit of SS, and maybe Reapers.

     

    I'd love for the proper US tour gigs to get the same medley as they played at RAH. Sadly that's prob our only chance of hearing even bits of those songs ever again.

     

    Good luck to everyone going to this gig. With such a short set, I hope they at least throw you a bone and stick one or two goodies in there (Open with Algorithm at the very least).

  7. So, I have an extra MEDIUM shirt if anyone forgot to buy one and wants it. I bought a small and a medium bc the sizes were so discrepant and didn't know which would fit. Turns out I'm keeping the small, so if anyone wants to buy the medium for what it cost (£25), lmk.

     

    I am leaving London tomorrow so if you want it, you can meet me somewhere tomorrow by noon or you'll have to pay for me to ship it to you from the US.

  8. Quick thoughts:

     

    I loved the Medley, but I am also American, so if we get that at our gigs, it will be great. I'd love to have NB in full though as a closer.

     

    I loved BITM.

     

    Crowd looked good from the first level of boxes. A nice circle pit appeared during Knights in the center of the floor:LOL:

     

    I took a few vids -- the medley, algo, showbiz, unsustainable. it was a decent angle I think:

     

    good for you Jobby getting the drumstick!

     

    those signs...ugh. I heard people were doing that and while it's a good notion, I just don't think during a gig like this is the place for it.

  9. Tbf those are 3 of their absolute best songs (including live) and you list those first 4 like they’re feasible when 3 of them have been dead for 6-12 years. Like, I’d love to see HTAILY but it doesn’t even come close to creeping into my hopes for the tour, y’know? :chuckle:

     

    well I know, but they fit in so well with the tone, I think. Don't get me wrong, I know there's zero chance any of them will be played, but what I'm saying is that if ONE of them was, it would elevate the setlist from shit to amazing. One song is all it takes :D

  10. Ok, so this is what I'm anticipating for the US tour.

     

    Basically the setlist last night in NY is the meh (excepting new songs) that we are used to, and I expect every one of those songs to be played at every US gig. The set was 50 mins, so that leaves about 40 mins (if we are lucky enough to get a whole 90 minute set, which is not guaranteed by any means).

     

    algorithm

    psycho

    pressure

    hysteria

    SH

    Propaganda

    PiB

    Madness

    TDS

    SMBH

    TIRO

    Starlight

    DD(gospel)

    Mercy

    uprising

    ---

    TC

    GUAF

    knights

     

    IMO this is a horrible setlist but likely. I figure there is a decent chance we get IS or TAB thrown in there somewhere. Oh and I forgot Resistance. I'm so gd sick of that song but they love to play it here. They're more likely to play that than PiB tbh.

     

    It's sad because I think the rock medley that Matt was referring to was for the stadiums, we certainly won't get that here. I'd LOVE to just get one or two songs out of MK, Exo-politics, RBS, Panic Station. Realistically the only (rare-not-rare) songs we might get are TAB, Map, or Bliss. Those are the go-to it seems in the US when they feel the need to give us a pseudo-rarity. :stunned:

  11. I was just so thrilled to get seats I didn't bother to change the "flash seats" delivery... Do you have experience with this? Is it normal to not have gotten a message from them yet?

     

    TIA

     

    I just called them after seeing your post because I haven't gotten mine either. After sitting on hold for 20 mins I was told that the tickets won't be sent until "Nov 16 at 2pm," which I thought was oddly specific, but there you go! :D

  12. Are Muse less popular in the US than they are in Europe? US people posting here seem not to be concerned that gigs will sell out. I was terrified I might not get tickets!

    very much so. the only gigs here that will completely sell out are possibly NYC and LA.

  13. I think it'll be more along the lines of this. And yes, I hope I'm very wrong about this.

     

    Algorithm

    The Dark Side

    Pressure

    Hysteria

    Plug in Baby

    [iS]

    Psycho

    Though Contagion

    Super Massive Black Hole

    Madness

    Starlight

    [Jam]

    Propaganda

    Blockades

    Something Human

    Time is Running Out

    Mercy

    Dig Down

    Knights of Cydonia

     

    Uprising

    Get Up and Fight

    Take a Bow

     

    yeah this is pretty much worst-case scenario and my fear as well :( sadly, i'm fairly confident this is what we'll be getting in the States (except they'll figure out a way to shorten it even further)

  14. I do enjoy some of the songs from the new album and it's not like that's all they play. Let's say that I'm hoping to be pleasantly surprised that the new material will come to life in concert. Either way, Muse can still be one of the better live bands around on any given night and I've surely spent money in more frivolous ways over the years.

     

    Fair enough. I guess we are lucky in that there's always a chance of greatness, even if we aren't expecting it.

  15. Heh, one of the things that I told my wife years ago is that if they ever do a request-only concert in the U.S. I'm going, regardless of where it is. I honestly don't expect much this time around but they can't keep targeting A-tier concert prices and not give an A-tier concert. Something has to break.

     

    you'd think so, but they sell enough tickets to have not really felt the need to do it in a while. I guess they pull in just enough new fans every album that it makes up for the old ones that drop off!

     

    Sadly, I don't even feel like they're promoting an A-tier album this time around. I guess we'll see how it goes. I'm sure they'll have lots of cool lights.

     

    I couldn't imagine spending $ for a gig if I felt this way. To each their own!

×
×
  • Create New...